My father often said the two saddest words in the English language were, “if only.” I grew up in a two bedroom apartment for most of my life. It had one big window in each room and it overlooked a huge field. We had lovely antique furniture and my mother’s beautiful mahogany baby grand piano, which fit perfectly despite how very small our place was. Her parents bought it for her when she was ten and my mother studied classically for twenty years. I would often come home from school to find her playing “Claire de Lune,” which to this day is my favorite piece of music for the piano. Starting in kindergarten my mother tried to teach me to play. I loved to sing but never enjoyed learning the piano. As I look back I realize I just did not appreciate the riches I had in her which were literally at my fingertips. She tried for years but I fought her tooth and nail. I did excel in music, but vocally. And I regret not being able to play the piano well to this day. Right before my mother died she bought her namesake an electric piano for her third birthday; a smiling cat whose teeth formed the keys. I know she held a quiet hope that her granddaughter might want to study and play classical piano one day. Of her own volition, when my little one entered into kindergarten this year she asked if she could take piano. Looking into the cost, I discussed it with her father. He agreed and the next week she began taking lessons from a young woman who is in the Dallas Symphony Orchestra. I have an upright piano and, as I have sat these past several months with my daughter at the bench, more than anything I wish I could apologize to my mother; if only. Now I am the teacher and I see the unending patience she had with me. I also see the same anger and frustration coming out in my daughter that I had as a child when I didn’t get it right. It’s surreal actually … sitting on both sides. Apparently she is a very good student for her teacher. Perhaps that was part of why I didn’t value my lessons, since it was “just” my mother teaching me. And I honestly do not know how the poor woman survived without wine; I find it fortifying before I sit down to practice with my daughter. This picture is a still frame from a video I took yesterday at a retirement home, where our six year old played her first recital. She was not nervous at all and sat straight and tall at the keys; her little hands positioned perfectly. She played her entire piece without one wrong note. Her father was grinning ear to ear and I was so proud of her. It would have meant so much to my mother. I have often wondered if our loved ones can ever visit us somehow. I believe God sends us signs, if we only recognize them. Earlier that morning as my little one played her piece before we left, a robin appeared outside our window. While they are not uncommon, I have never seen one in our yard or pond. Suddenly I remembered the first song my mother ever taught me to play on the piano. It was about a little robin singing from her woodland tree. I had not thought about it since I was in kindergarten myself. The American novelist and poet Josiah Gilbert Holland once wrote, “God gives every bird its food, but He does not throw it into its nest.” I do not want my daughter to look back one day and say, “if only.” I suppose only time will tell if she has an inherent love for playing … or maybe, if I am lucky, a little robin might show me.